Insights · Hitting & development
The Car Ride Is Part of the Journey. Lead It.
“I love you” is about who your child is, not how they played. Say it all day. Then lead both car rides with honesty and good timing.
There’s a piece of advice that gets passed around youth sports every season. After the game, say five words, “I love to watch you play,” and then stay quiet. Let the kid decide whether there’s a conversation. Don’t bring up the game unless they do.
I don’t buy it.
It’s advice built around how the child feels in the moment, and it asks the parent to step out of the one role nobody else can fill. The car ride to the game and the car ride home are part of the sports journey. They aren’t something to survive in silence. They’re time a parent can lead.
“I love you” stands on its own
I love you is the most powerful thing you can say to your child, and they should hear it all their life. Not once after the game. Six times a day, ten times, 25, 100. Walking into the ballfield and walking out of it. That should be standard in your family.
What it shouldn’t be is attached to their performance.
When “I love you” gets wired to “watch you play,” it starts to sound like watching them play has something to do with your love. And when “I love to watch you play” comes out after a game where they played poorly, it doesn’t make much sense. They didn’t love playing poorly. Why would you love watching it? Kids know the difference.
So keep the three messages separate:
- I love you for being you. Always. Win, loss, 4-for-4, 0-for-4. It has nothing to do with the game.
- I enjoy watching you compete. When it’s true, say it. “I really enjoyed watching you play hard today.” “That was fun. You played fearless.” “It was awesome how you picked up your teammate after that error.” Specific and honest. It doesn’t need to be said on every ride home, and it shouldn’t be automatic.
- I’m your parent, and I’ll tell you when you don’t do things well. That’s part of the job. The timing is what matters.
Love isn’t up for review. The performance is, at the right time.
What the research actually says
The ride home has been studied, and the findings don’t say “go silent.” They point to timing, emotion and having a plan.
Bruce Brown and Rob Miller of Proactive Coaching spent years asking college athletes about their worst memory from youth and high school sports. It’s an informal poll, not a scientific study. The answer they kept hearing was the ride home from games with my parents [1][2]. The answer to their other question, what did your parents say that made you feel great, was most often “I love to watch you play” [1].
Read that closely. Players don’t resent their parents being part of the ride. They resent rides that turn into a cross-examination. And what made them feel great was knowing their parent valued them in the game. A parent can give them that without tying love to how they played: say “I love you” for who they are, and save “I enjoyed watching you” for when it’s true.
University of Toronto researchers interviewed 27 athletes ages 11 to 16, in sports including baseball, along with one of their parents, about the drive home [3]. Both parents and athletes tended to see parent feedback as normal and necessary for getting better. The researchers didn’t tell parents to stop talking. Their advice was to let emotions cool before you speak, talk with your child about what the ride home should be, and set “rules of the road” together [4]. In other words: have a plan.
An Australian study of 86 parents and children in junior football looked at the postgame “debrief” [5]. Most parents saw reviewing the game as part of being a good sports parent. Kids valued real praise. What upset them was critical comments right after a loss or a game they were already unhappy with, and some of those debriefs turned into arguments.
So the problem isn’t honesty, and it isn’t the parent talking. It’s emotion, timing, and having no plan.
The ride to the game: mental prep
The ride there is the most overlooked part of game day. It should be mental preparation, led by the parent or by the player, and the family should decide which ahead of time.
For some players that means quiet and music. For others it means talking through the plan. Who’s pitching, what he likes to throw, what the approach is in the first at-bat, what “playing hard” looks like today. A player who walks into the dugout with a plan has already won something, whatever the box score says.
The ride home: planned by the family, adjusted to the moment
The ride home should be whatever the family has planned and whatever the moment needs. Sometimes that’s a celebration. Sometimes it’s quiet for 20 minutes and then a real conversation. Sometimes it’s a hard conversation that can’t wait.
A few principles make it work:
1. Set the rules before the season. Decide as a family what the ride home looks like after a win, after a loss, and after a bad game. The player can help write the rules, but the parent leads.
2. Know whose lane is whose. The swing, the approach and the lineup belong to the coach. Effort, attitude, body language and how your child treats teammates and umpires belong to the family. That’s where a parent’s voice matters most.
3. Let emotions settle, but don’t dodge. Cooling off isn’t the same as avoiding. If something needs to be said, say it when it can be heard, on the ride or after dinner.
4. Ask before you tell. “What was your plan in that at-bat?” “How do you think you competed today?” “What’s one thing you’ll do differently?” A player who can answer those honestly is learning to coach himself.
5. Call out effort when it isn’t there. If your child plays a lazy game, “I love to watch you play” and silence isn’t support. It’s avoidance. Don’t fake the praise, and don’t mix the hard talk with “I love you.” The “I love you” already happened walking out of the ballfield, and it’ll happen again tonight. The honest conversation comes when it can be heard: “That wasn’t your best effort today. That’s not who we are. What happened?” That’s leadership, and it’s the conversation a player will remember as the moment someone held him to a standard.
Build the hitter. Build the person.
That balance of love that never changes, honest standards and a real plan is what parent-led development looks like. It’s also the idea behind the Do Damage Performance Lab, which I’m building for athletes 13 and older and their families.
The player follows a measured process: test, train, record the real number, retest, adjust. He reviews his own work and owns it. The parent leads the environment, sets the expectations, holds the standard and celebrates the effort. Parents are not substitute hitting coaches, and they shouldn’t have to be.
It isn’t designed to replace hitting instructors, coaches, teams or in-person development. IT TAKES A VILLAGE TO RAISE A HITTER. It’s designed to help the player better understand, and increasingly own, their development.
THE PARENT HELPS ESTABLISH THE ENVIRONMENT. THE PLAYER LEARNS TO TAKE OWNERSHIP OF THE PROCESS.
Karl Carswell is a hitting consultant, former Major League Baseball scout and founder of Damage Hitter in Overland Park, Kansas. He has spent more than three decades evaluating and developing baseball players, with scouting experience across eight MLB organizations, USA Baseball and the Area Code Games. Read Karl Carswell’s full biography →
Sources & Further Reading
- “Rethink the conversation on the car ride home,” Herald-Star (Steubenville, Ohio), March 11, 2013, reporting Bruce E. Brown and Rob Miller’s informal survey of college athletes. https://www.heraldstaronline.com/sports/sports-columns/2013/03/rethink-the-conversation-on-the-car-ride-home/
- Bruce E. Brown, “I Loved the Ride Home With My Dad,” Proactive Coaching, Sept. 10, 2026. https://www.proactivecoaching.ai/i-loved-the-ride-home-with-my-dad/
- Tamminen, K. A., Poucher, Z. A., & Povilaitis, V. (2017). “The car ride home: An interpretive examination of parent–athlete sport conversations.” Sport, Exercise, and Performance Psychology, 6(4), 325–339. https://doi.org/10.1037/spy0000093
- “After the game: How parents can improve the car ride home with young athletes,” University of Toronto News, Oct. 4, 2017. https://www.utoronto.ca/news/after-game-how-parents-can-improve-car-ride-home-young-athletes
- Elliott, S. K., & Drummond, M. J. N. (2015). “Parents in youth sport: what happens after the game?” Sport, Education and Society. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/13573322.2015.1036233