Insights · Hitting & development

Projection vs. Production: How Scouts Evaluate Players, Old School and New School

Every scout who watches a player is answering two questions at the same time.

What is he right now? And what will he become?

The first question is about production: the stats, the results, what happened on the field this season. The second is about projection: what the player’s body, tools, skills and makeup could turn into three, five or seven years from now.

Players and parents tend to focus on the first question. Scouts are paid to answer the second. I’ve spent more than three decades evaluating and developing baseball players, and the gap between those two questions is where most of the confusion about recruiting, rankings and “being good enough” comes from.

The old-school way: the eye, the stopwatch and the 20-80 scale

Long before anyone had a launch-angle reading, scouts graded players on the 20-80 scale. Branch Rickey, the executive who built baseball’s first farm system, is generally credited with creating it, and every major league organization still uses a version of it today.

On that scale, 50 is major league average, 60 is above average, and 70-80 is well above average. Scouts grade the five classic tools for position players: hitting, power, running, fielding and throwing.

The key is that every tool gets two grades: present and future. According to FanGraphs, present grades on high school players are often 20s, while in the upper minor leagues the gap between present and future grades is very small. A tool written as 20/50 means “well below average today, projects to be major league average.”

All of it rolls up into one number, the Overall Future Potential (OFP), sometimes called the future overall grade. It isn’t an average of the tools. It’s the scout’s single judgment of what the player will ultimately be in the big leagues. MLB.com describes a future grade of 65 or better as a potential impact major leaguer, perhaps an All-Star-caliber player.

Notice what’s missing from that system: batting average. The old-school report was never really about the stat line. It was about the stopwatch (home to first, the 60-yard dash), the radar gun, the way the ball came off the bat, how the body was likely to fill out, and what kind of competitor the player was. Projection was the whole job.

The new-school way: measure everything

Today, measurement has changed the game at every level.

Year What changed in MLB measurement
2015 Statcast goes league-wide, using radar and cameras to track every pitch and batted ball
2020 Hawk-Eye’s 12-camera optical tracking system replaces the original setup in all 30 ballparks
2023 High-frame-rate cameras are added for bat and biomechanics tracking
2023 MLB uses Uplift Labs motion-capture technology to collect biomechanics data on draft prospects at the Draft Combine
2024 MLB begins publishing bat-tracking data: swing speed and swing path

Sources: MLB.com Statcast glossary; MLB Technology Blog (March 2023); MLB.com (May 2024); Sports Business Journal (June 2023).

The same kinds of measurements, exit velocity, bat speed, spin and movement, now show up at college programs, showcases and training facilities across the country. A player can walk out of a session with more objective data than a big league scout had on a first-round pick a generation ago.

That’s a good thing. Numbers remove some of the guessing. They expose a swing that looks pretty but doesn’t produce, and they reveal a player whose raw tools are better than his stat line.

But measurement mostly describes the present. An exit-velocity reading tells you how hard a player hit the ball today. It doesn’t tell you how hard he’ll hit it at 22.

The draft proves projection is hard

If projection were easy, the draft would be predictable. It isn’t.

Baseball America studied every draft from 1981 to 2010. Only 17.6% of players who were drafted and signed reached the major leagues, fewer than one in five. Even at the top, projection misses:

Round drafted (1981-2010) Share who reached MLB
1st round 73%
2nd round 51%
3rd round 40%
All drafted and signed players 17.6%

Source: Baseball America, “How Many MLB Draftees Make It To The Majors” (2019).

More than one in four first-round picks, players evaluated by dozens of professional scouts, never played a single major league game.

The misses go the other way too. In 1988 the Dodgers took Mike Piazza with the 1,390th pick, in the 62nd round. According to the National Baseball Hall of Fame, he is the lowest-drafted Hall of Famer in history. In 1999 the Cardinals took Albert Pujols in the 13th round, 402nd overall. Every team passed on each of them, many times over.

Age is another part of projection that the market has historically gotten wrong. Baseball Prospectus analyst Rany Jazayerli studied high school hitters taken in the top 100 picks from 1965 to 1996. Teams that drafted one of the five youngest high school hitters in a class could expect more than twice as much value as teams that drafted one of the five oldest. A 2014 study in the Journal of Sports Economics reached a similar conclusion for the 1987-2011 drafts: teams undervalued younger high school players.

Why would age matter so much? Because a younger player with the same production has more development time in front of him. Two players can post identical numbers, and the one who’s 11 months younger may be the better prospect.

Why current stats can mislead

This is where players and parents get stuck. A high school or travel-ball stat line is real, and it matters, but by itself it can’t answer the scout’s second question. Here’s why:

  1. Competition varies wildly. A .450 average against below-average pitching and a .300 average against top competition don’t mean the same thing.
  2. Age and physical maturity distort results. An early-maturing 16-year-old can dominate now and stall later. A late bloomer can look ordinary now and project better than anyone on the field.
  3. Small samples lie. A high school season is often 25 to 35 games. A hot or cold month can swing the whole line.
  4. Results hide the process. A ground ball through the hole and a hard line drive caught at the wall count the opposite way in the box score. The second one may tell you more about the hitter.

None of this means stats don’t matter. It means production is evidence, not a verdict.

The best evaluators use both

The old-school scout and the new-school analyst aren’t enemies. The best evaluators today do both: they use the measurement to sharpen what the eye sees, and they use the eye to understand what the measurement can’t capture.

At Damage Hitter, we put it this way: Old-school development. New-school measurement.

We test because the numbers are honest. But we also know where the numbers stop. MEASURE EVERYTHING WORTH MEASURING WITHOUT PRETENDING EVERYTHING WORTH KNOWING IS MEASURABLE. Makeup, coachability, competitiveness and intent are a big part of every projection, and none of them appear on a sensor.

And most important: Data informs development. Data does not define the player’s identity. A ranking, a showcase score or a single season’s average is a snapshot. Projection is a forecast. Development is what changes the forecast.

That’s why our methodology is built around the 5 Ds:

  • DISCOVER — Test where you are.
  • DIAGNOSE — Identify what is limiting performance.
  • DEVELOP — Train with your individualized plan.
  • DOCUMENT — Measure and track progress.
  • DO DAMAGE — Compete. Retest. Rebuild. Repeat.

The first four are how a player turns a future grade into a present one. The fifth is where he proves it, and then starts the cycle again. The 5 Ds are THE development cycle, not a one-time marketing funnel.

What players and parents should take from this

  1. Know which question you’re being asked. College coaches and pro scouts are projecting. Don’t assume a great stat line answers everything, or that an average one ends the conversation.
  2. Measure, and keep measuring. One test is a snapshot. Retesting over time shows the trend, and the trend is what projection is really about.
  3. Respect development time. Younger and later-maturing players often have the most room to grow. Patience is part of the plan.
  4. Develop what the numbers can’t see. Approach, competitiveness, coachability and intent are part of every serious evaluation.

The scout’s job is to predict who a player will become. The player’s job is to make that prediction too low.

BUILD THE HITTER. BUILD THE PERSON.

Sources: FanGraphs, “Scouting Explained: The 20-80 Scouting Scale” (2014); MLB.com glossary, “Scouting Grades” and “Statcast”; Baseball Prospectus glossary, OFP; MLB Technology Blog, “Introducing Statcast 2023” (March 2023); MLB.com, “Statcast bat tracking” (May 2024); Sports Business Journal, MLB and Uplift Labs (June 2023); Baseball America, “How Many MLB Draftees Make It To The Majors” (2019); National Baseball Hall of Fame, “Pick a Pair: Hall of Fame Class of 2016 makes draft history”; MLB.com, Albert Pujols player bio; Rany Jazayerli, “Doctoring the Numbers: Starting Them Young,” Baseball Prospectus (October 2011); “Hurdle Models and Age Effects in the Major League Baseball Draft,” Journal of Sports Economics (2014).

Karl Carswell is a hitting consultant, former Major League Baseball scout and founder of Damage Hitter in Overland Park, Kansas. He has spent more than three decades evaluating and developing baseball players, with scouting experience across eight MLB organizations, USA Baseball and the Area Code Games. Read Karl Carswell’s full biography →